Creative Economy and Public Policies

By Claudia Leitao

1. What is fundamental for a solid creative economy policy in Brazil? What are the needs and demands not met by existing policies?

The first and biggest challenge for public policies for the Creative Economy in Brazil refers to agreeing on a concept for the creative economy. A first obstacle faced in this process of conceptual construction concerns the terminology adopted in the field of Creative Economy, due to the fact that most publications and debates on the subject are of Anglo-Saxon origin. In addition to being inadequate due to the specificities of each country, it is reckless to simply translate concepts that often generate semantic misunderstandings due to cultural differences. The expression creative industries – generally adopted by Anglo-Saxon countries and even by Latin and Asian countries – is translated in Brazil literally as 'creative industries'. However, in English the term 'industry' means 'sector' or the group of companies that carry out a common productive activity (e.g. the automobile sector, the clothing sector, etc.). This tends to generate a series of cognitive noises due to the close association that is commonly made in Brazil between the term 'industry' and large-scale, mass-produced and serial manufacturing activities. It is impossible not to recognize the persistence of semantic noises between creative economies and creative industries, with ambiguous impacts on the economy of culture.

A second challenge concerns the frameworks of international organizations, which end up encouraging hierarchies between typologies and subjecting the non-industrial sectors of the creative economy to the dominance of cultural and creative industries. Reports from international organizations legitimize hegemonies and (re)produce concealments and absences. Typologies, categories, and glossaries are complex products, especially in the face of hybrid cultures. Each cultural sector can be understood from an industrial perspective. From music to crafts, from festivals to tourism, cultural expressions are dressed up, disguised, or disguised in the name of the most diverse interests, which are in constant dispute. Global reports on the creative economy should assume greater responsibility in the struggle to decolonize concepts. Therefore, they should not treat emerging epistemologies as mere 'case studies'. Creative industries are understood as an expansion of cultural industries, in the name of a definition of the creative economy that does not reveal asymmetries, but that hides the tensions and disputes of the development model of the global capitalist system. 

The third challenge concerns the lack of an effective public policy for the production of reliable data about the cultural and creative sectors, with emphasis on the production of new indicators. The hegemony of theoretical frameworks, concepts and methodologies, which privilege creative industries to the detriment of creative economies, ratifies the dominance of epistemologies from the global North and their universal postulates over epistemologies from the South. Public policies for the creative economy must broaden the meanings of development (with involvement), strengthening solidarity and contributing to the composting of new fertilizers for the reinvention of the human. It is urgent that new ways of knowing, other epistemologies, be integrated into international and national reports on the creative economy, which allow the visibility of creative territories and communities across the planet.

The fourth challenge, which arises in the face of the crisis of the global world-system, is the urgency of a new presence of the State, which is no longer justified only to neutralize asymmetries produced by neoliberal visions, nor to carry out an exacerbated interventionism, which produces new forms of dependence.  In a network society, the expectation of efficient, effective and efficient public policies cannot do without reinventing the State itself. In transforming the social contract into a social agreement, the State and Society must assume new roles and partnerships, especially in bringing public interests closer to common goods. In this sense, the challenge for Brazilian governments (whether at the federal, state or municipal level) would be to recognize and support the economic, cultural, environmental, political and social dynamics of creative goods and services, which weave networks and create communities, with a view to emancipation and development with involvement. This understanding of the creative economy is based on the meanings of development proposed by Celso Furtado: on the one hand, the human capacity to create original solutions to the specific problems of a society; on the other, the emphasis on the creative impulse of communities in the release of human energies in favor of emancipation and involvement. However, the creative economy will only achieve its purposes based on the principles and values that constitute it. 

2. What are the main opportunities for the Brazilian creative economy? Do the ongoing transformations bring relevant opportunities? (such as digitalization, new technologies, sustainable economy, etc.)

3. What are the challenges and opportunities for the inclusion of historically marginalized groups, such as women, black people, LGBTQIAP+ and people with disabilities, in the creative economy? How can we ensure more equitable participation and empowerment of these groups?

To face the challenges of formulating, implementing and monitoring, in short, the governance of public policies for the Creative Economy, it is necessary to define principles that underpin this economy:

  1. The creative economy as an economy of citizenship and democracy

We must understand the meanings of citizenship and democracy, beyond the legal-political abstractions proposed by Modernity, but, above all, from the return to the territory, as a used territory., as Milton Santos (1994) proposes. The territory contains the resources and infrastructures to be managed by communities to learn to know, learn to do, learn to be and learn to live together. The principle of citizenship and democracy, which underpin the creative economy, guide these uses and their respective dynamics. For the creative economy, prioritizing ethos The community and its uses of the territory are essential for development with involvement. It is not a matter of perceiving and measuring the creative economy in an abstract and deterritorialized way, based on the mere economic performance of the creative sectors, but, above all, of understanding it through its impacts on 'weaving networks' and 'creating communities'. The creative economy must also be conceived as an invention of democratic culture (freedoms, guarantees of rights) and citizen culture (solidarity, participation, sharing). Through the creative economy, we can resume, revive and deepen the meanings of citizenship and cultural democracy: whether as an affirmation of the rights and duties of the individual in relation to other individuals, or of a community in relation to other communities, with regard to the responsible uses of territories, in favor of citizenship and democracy. Public policies for a citizen-based and democratic creative economy would be those that guarantee creative communities, artists, and other professionals in the creative sectors the ability to establish objectives, define priorities, control resources and manage infrastructures to solve problems, fulfill desires, learning to be, to know, to do and to live together, in order to reinforce the values of development with involvement.

  1. The creative economy as an economy of cultural biodiversity and technodiversity

It is necessary to reclaim the meanings of culture as cultivation and care for the land, which gives rise to the word agriculture (CHAUÍ, 2009, p.21), in order to expand its prominence in a new development agenda. Natural disasters, global warming, the resurgence of pandemics, and unsustainable life in cities are symptoms of a sick planet, which demand a less rhetorical and more effective commitment to sustainability from governments and companies. The growth of social movements around ecological causes also points to the urgency of a national policy for Brazilian cultural biodiversity. The principle of cultural biodiversity expands the meanings of culture, while bringing the creative economy closer to the solidarity economy, the bioeconomy, the circular economy, the green economy, fair trade, responsible consumption, that is, to substantive values, around collaboration and care, essential to development with involvement. The presence of NGOs and community leaders reinforces the importance of youth leadership, which transforms traditional knowledge into contemporary cultural products on a daily basis, based on new business models, in search of sustainable alternatives for living. It is also important to acknowledge the recurring misconception about the rational and unifying role of technologies, which are considered an end and not a means of promoting cultural diversity. We know that technological acceleration was decisive for globalization and that technological differences reinforce asymmetries. Therefore, it is necessary to avoid monolithic and evolutionist interpretations about the place of technologies in the construction of society. Technologies continue to be tools, limited to the variables of utility and efficiency and, in this sense, should not imprison ethics or aesthetics. On the other hand, education in the digital age must start from the assumption that the use of technologies and techniques is not at the service of a unifying hegemonic discourse, but, on the contrary, should allow and support the diversity of narratives and their contents.  

  1. The creative economy as an innovative economy

How can artists and workers in small cultural and creative enterprises in the countries of the South, most of which operate informally, be protagonists of innovation? An innovative creative economy cannot do without public policies arising from an Entrepreneurial State, which takes risks and invests in an innovative culture. Mariana Mazzucato observes that, among the myths to be confronted by the Entrepreneurial State, is the one that determines the causal link between innovation and research & development, a reality naturally associated with the industrial world. Innovation is a much broader concept and should be understood as a strategy for productive inclusion. Public policies for an innovative creative economy are those that do not contribute to “picking winners”, that is, those that confront the asymmetries of the free market through a more prospective than reactive behavior, in favor of cultural and creative workers. It is the task of the Entrepreneurial State to promote innovation in small businesses, ensuring the conditions for the balance of creative ecosystems that are favorable to small businesses, as well as to stimulate virtuous cycles in the economic dynamics of creative goods and services, focusing above all on open innovation for small entrepreneurs, whether formal or informal. The creative economy as an innovative economy cannot do without critical thinking and political will that are capable of perceiving the ambiguities, dilemmas and impasses of innovation, that is, its possibilities for emancipation, but also its senses of dependence and domination. Cultural innovation, as open innovation, is symbolic of the role of cultural goods and services beyond satisfying markets, but as an effective possibility for expanding citizenship, based on the expansion of cultural capital and emancipation. Numerous innovative projects in the field of culture and the creative economy have been creating a new landscape in the world of networks. These are encouraging examples that give concrete meaning to the meanings of creativity as emancipation, responsibility, solidarity and, above all, reinvention and expansion of citizenship. We are faced with creative communities that are born in a physical territory, but that take flight in virtual territories, which mobilize a great diversity of actors, producing new nexuses and connections in networks. Public policies for an innovative creative economy are those that recognize, make visible, reveal, expand and connect creative communities.

  1. The creative economy as a sustainable economy

Public policies for the sustainability of the creative economy must commit to territorial governance that reflects the values of involvement, collaboration and conviviality, encouraging new economic practices based on these values. They must also recognize the strategic role of traditional communities and their cultural practices in favor of development with involvement. Knowing them in order to learn from them is a necessity and an urgent matter, which cannot be achieved through mere repositories, mapping or diagnostics. Expanding and qualifying the management of territorial resources in favor of healthy cultural habits also constitutes an essential challenge, whether in the management of common goods (sustainable use of water, clean energy, protection of biodiversity), or in the economic dynamics of sustainable production, distribution and consumption of creative goods and services. From food culture to gastronomy, from crafts to design, we observe that human creativity gains substance, whether in its artisanal or industrial production. It is the task of public policies to address the asymmetries between industries and crafts in favor of sustainability, instead of constructing uncritical and laudatory discourses about the growth of creative sectors in countries' GDP. Inequality is, by nature, unsustainable. It reveals the dark side of thousands of cultural workers, subjected to precariousness, informality and exploitation. The 2030 Agenda for Sustainable Development has encouraged countries to overcome the following challenges through culture and creativity: identifying the cultural factors of poverty, ensuring dignified working conditions in the creative economy, secure access to information, but also to credit and financing, education focused on creative skills for young people, new uses of cultural heritage, valuing and protecting common goods, commitment of creative industries to the sustainability of their products and processes (use of water and clean energy), the transversality of the creative economy in various government departments, credits targeted at creative communities, infrastructure necessary for the dynamics of creation, production, distribution and consumption of creative goods and services, legal frameworks that contribute to consolidating and protecting creative ecosystems and the creative economy, are some of the challenges of a sustainable creative economy, whose contribution is invaluable for achieving development with involvement. 

  1. The creative economy as an economy of productive inclusion

Is a cultural policy that contributes to the economic development of territories and populations an economic policy? And, conversely, is an economic policy that recognizes and supports the dynamics of creation, production, distribution and consumption of symbolic goods and services also a cultural policy? These questions are strategic for us to understand the hybrid nature of the creative economy. Informality is the field of invisibility, disconnection, absence and diminishment of the worker in the capitalist world-economy and constitutes one of its most perverse effects, especially in the field of creative economies of the countries of the South. Much more a process than a product, a quality of governance and management of territorial resources than a sectoral performance measured by GDP, the Brazilian creative economy has as its primary task to expand the indicators of the creative economy to reveal the intangible, the invisible and the inaudible. Ultimately, informality is a symptom of an economic system that annihilates and hides creative forces, marginalizing them from civil and human rights and the exercise of citizenship. How can we recognize the presence of cultural and creative workers in the informal sector, who are always invisible in international and national reports on the creative economy? Public policies for the creative economy, in their task of productive inclusion, must productively include Brazilian youth, who have historically been deprived of the right to creativity. In this sense, productive inclusion necessarily implies educating youth in creative skills. In the field of the creative economy, the Entrepreneurial State is the one that formulates a policy of investment and synergies between art, culture, scientific and non-scientific knowledge, and technologies, around a new development agenda. As already noted, innovation cannot and should not be reduced to the mere support of startups and business incubation, but rather expanded, through innovative forms, to the incubation of communities. The Entrepreneurial State in the field of the creative economy is the one that guarantees, through the structuring and strengthening of creative ecosystems, the effective presence of creative energies in the various domains of social life. Its role is not only to correct market failures or prioritize investments in certain sectors, but to encourage a broad development policy based on inclusion, an essential principle for the realization of citizenship and democracy.

  1. The creative economy as an economy of the common good

To imagine and implement a creative economy based on the principle of the common good is to affirm a new epistemology that opposes the hegemonic conceptions of creative industries, built on the values of private property, the cult of the individual and competitiveness. In the blue economy, the common good to be protected is water; in the bioeconomy, biomes; in the circular economy, the sustainability of processes; in the solidarity economy, collaborative practices. All these economies, which react to the global capitalist system, choose their assets, prioritizing resources that value and safeguard the common good. If forests, dolphins, indigenous peoples, drinking water, fair prices, memory, honesty and other assets are at risk of disappearing, the most concrete counterpoint to the planet's death drive is found in the networks that are woven in the territory. The great challenge for contemporary societies is to bring culture closer to the territory. To this end, it is necessary to develop an ecology of economic dynamics that is capable of better managing resources in the territory and choosing its new assets, based on the principles of the common good and good living. The creative economy, like the economy of the common good, tests the existence of other ways of living and, in this sense, frees the word economy from a rationality that reduces the human. Ultimately, it is precisely because it is cooperative, collaborative, supportive, civic and sustainable that the creative economy is an economy. 

  1. The creative economy as an economy of good living

In the midst of the global crisis, especially the climate crisis, Buen Vivir is gaining ever greater symbolic strength, which is expressed in community struggles in favor of cooperative and non-extractive forms of land use. The first major transformation advocated by Buen Vivir is the break with anthropocentrism; the second is the reaction to the reduction of development to its mercantile dimension; the third refers to the decolonization of thought, not only confronting Eurocentrism and the impacts of the Anthropocene on the planet, but also emphasizing the principles of plurinationality and bioegalitarianism, originating from indigenous peoples. Intrinsic values are recognized, and nature becomes a subject; the human as the only source of values is therefore displaced. The vision promoted by Buen Vivir strongly supports the need to explore alternatives for development beyond traditional Eurocentric knowledge. Therefore, decolonialism is a component that Buen Vivir proposes (including the work of indigenous intellectuals such as David Kopenawa, Ailton Krenak, and Daniel Mundurukú). This decolonization opens the door to different forms of understanding, rationality, and feelings about the world. On the other hand, Buen Vivir also respects its internal plurality of conceptions, without hierarchy. The classical liberal vision of multiculturalism is insufficient for this purpose, so an intercultural vision is necessary. Buen Vivir is more than the simple coexistence or juxtaposition of different cultures, because they interact in dialogue and praxis focused on promoting alternatives to development. Buen Vivir promotes the dissolution of the Society-Nature dualism. Nature becomes part of the social world, and political communities can extend in some cases to non-humans. This includes, for example, not only proposals from biocentric environmental perspectives, but also indigenous positions that recognize that non-humans (whether animals, plants, ecosystems, or spirits) have desires and feelings. With this, the polis is expanded, and the concept of citizenship is broadened to include these other actors with their environmental configurations.


Bibliographic Reference
LEITÃO, Claudia Sousa. Creativity and emancipation in network communities: contributions to a Brazilian creative economy. São Paulo: Itaú Cultural; Martins Fontes publishing house, 2023.

Claudia Leitao
Cláudia Leitão holds a PhD in Sociology from the Sorbonne (Paris V) and a Master's in Law from the University of São Paulo. She was Secretary of Culture for the State of Ceará (2003-2006) and Secretary of the Creative Economy for the Ministry of Culture (2011-2013). She directed the Fortaleza Observatory of the Planning Institute of the City of Fortaleza – IPLANFOR (2017-2020) and was president of the Sector Chamber of Creative Economy at the Development Agency of the State of Ceará – ADECE (2019-2020). She is a member of the Advisory Board of the Portuguese company Territórios Criativos (2020), an associate consultant at the Alvorada Brasil Institute and an ad hoc consultant on Creative Economy for the World Trade Organization (WTO) and the United Nations Conference on Trade and Development (UNCTAD). She is a partner at the Celso Furtado International Center for Development Policies and Tempo de Hermes Projetos Criativos. She is a professor of the Professional Master's Degree in Tourism Business Management at the State University of Ceará.